If you’re contemplating the purchase of a Green Egg, you’re likely considering the best size for your space, cooking needs, and lifestyle. The Big Green Egg (BGE) is a beloved ceramic kamado-style grill that’s known for its versatility, efficiency, and excellent heat retention. But the question remains: should I get a medium or large green egg? This guide will walk you through the features, benefits, and considerations for each size, helping you decide which one will make the perfect addition to your backyard or outdoor kitchen.
Understanding the Big Green Egg
Before jumping into the size comparison, it’s important to understand what makes the Big Green Egg unique in the world of grilling. The BGE is not just a grill—it’s a high-performance, multi-functional cooking device that can be used for grilling, smoking, baking, roasting, and even searing at high temperatures.
Made in the USA from a proprietary ceramic material, each Green Egg maintains heat efficiently and ensures even cooking across all temperature ranges. Their patented air flow system gives you precise control, making the Big Green Egg a favorite among both amateurs and seasoned barbecue enthusiasts.
The BGE comes in a range of sizes: mini, small, medium, large, and extra large. For most households or serious cooking enthusiasts, the two most popular sizes are the medium (M) and large (L) models. Each offers distinct advantages depending on usage, number of guests, available space, and budget.
Comparing the Medium Big Green Egg vs. the Large Green Egg
Understanding the physical differences between the two models is crucial for making an informed decision. Let’s take a closer look at each Green Egg size:
Dimensions & Cooking Area
| Feature | Medium Big Green Egg | Large Big Green Egg |
|———|———————-+———————|
| Cooking height (without convEGGtor) | ~19.5” | ~22.5” |
| Cooking surface width | ~18.25” | ~24.5” |
| Total cooking area (primary and secondary grates) | ~410 sq. in | ~625 sq. in |
| Internal volume | ~5 cubic feet | ~8 cubic feet |
| Egg height | ~34” (without cart) | ~36” (without cart) |
| Weight | ~162 lbs (without stand) | ~180 lbs (without stand) |
The medium provides a compact yet capable setup for regular backyard use, while the large offers significantly more surface area—nearly 50% more—making it suited for big gatherings, larger cuts of meat (like whole turkeys), or serious weekend cookouts.
Uses and Practical Considerations
Medium Egg (M): This size is ideal for couples, families of 3-5, camping, or urban settings with limited space. It heats up faster than the large and is slightly more portable, especially when placed on a rolling cart.
Large Egg (L): With more cooking surface and volume, the large is a favorite for entertaining. You can cook for around 10 people with ease, have multiple heat zones, and even set up for full Kamado-style baking and smoking. It’s better suited for patios, outdoor kitchens, or yards where it can be permanently stationed.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Medium and Large
Deciding between the medium and large Big Green Egg isn’t just about size—it’s about your specific lifestyle and how you plan to use your Egg.
Available Space
Make sure to measure your outdoor cooking space before shopping. The medium is slightly shorter and lighter, making it suitable for decks, balconies, smaller patios, and built-in grill carts. The large model requires a sturdier setup and more real estate, especially if you plan to use accessories like a heat deflector plate (convEGGtor), dual grates, or pizza stones.
Cooking Frequency and Volume
Consider how often you grill and how many people you’ll be cooking for:
- If you’re cooking for a family or couple 2-3 nights a week, the medium might be more than enough.
- If you host parties and enjoy smoking briskets, whole birds, or hosting dinner events regularly, the extra capacity of the large will serve you better.
The large also allows for separation of different protein or dishes on the heat zones simultaneously, a great advantage for complex cooking.
Heating and Fuel Efficiency
The Big Green Egg ceramic is known for excellent insulation, but larger models obviously need more fuel and time to reach cooking temperature. The medium can be heated fully in about 15–30 minutes; the large may take up to an hour, especially when using the Egg for low-and-slow smoking.
However, both models retain heat like a champ. The large may be a better pick for fuel-efficiency in long, multi-hour cooks, as the Egg sustains a consistent temperature longer when fully loaded with charcoal and heat stabilized.
Transportation and Mobility
Though both models are heavy for a grill, the medium Egg’s lighter weight and slightly smaller footprint can make it easier to move around. If you’re considering a mobile base or planning to take the Egg on camping trips, the medium has a practical edge.
The large is best left on a stationary cart or countertop setup, especially with accessories such as a sideboard or heat deflectors attached.
Upgrades and Accessories Compatibility
Whether you plan to get the Medium or Large, you’ll have access to the full suite of BGE accessories—dual grates, convEGGtor, stainless steel grids, cutting boards, pizza stones, and more.
However, you need to match accessories to your Egg size:
- Medium Egg items won’t fit on Large Eggs, but Large sized accessories can be used on both Large and Medium by adjusting configurations.
So if you’re planning for future accessory upgrades or want the most flexibility, starting with the Large Egg might make sense.
Which Size Big Green Egg Is Best for Specific User Types?
To make the choice even more tailored, let’s break it down based on real-world user scenarios.
For Singles or Newlyweds
If you’re cooking for one or two people with regularity, the Medium Big Green Egg fits the bill perfectly. It provides a great cooking experience without wasting fuel or taking up too much space. Most couples preparing weekend steaks, burgers, or grilled vegetables will find the Medium more than adequate.
For Small Families (3–5 People)
The medium is still a great option, but depending on how often you host or host during weekends, the Large can offer greater flexibility. For instance, if you have teenagers or enjoy hosting neighborhood BBQs, a larger model will prevent having to cook in shifts.
For Large Families or Entertaining Enthusiasts
If your cooking often extends to 6+ people at one time, the extra cooking area of the Large Egg will justify the investment. Roasting a whole turkey or smoking 3 racks of ribs and a brisket? The Large makes it effortless and efficient.
For Grillers Who Double as Outdoor Chefs
The Large Egg excels for those who want to do more than basic grilling. Its internal volume and versatility allow for:
- Home-style pizza ovens with a pizza stone
- Smoking at consistent, low temperatures for 8+ hours
- Vertical roasting using a cooking rack
- Even baking bread or casseroles with the lid closed
This is where the Large really shines, offering much more space for creativity through advanced cooking techniques.
For Urban Cookers (Balconies, Rooftops, Small Yards)
If you’re living in a condo or apartment with a limited outdoor footprint, the Medium might be your only viable option. You may also need to confirm if local fire codes or building rules allow ceramic grills in your living situation.
Smaller wheels, lighter cart, or a portable base are also easier to maneuver in limited spaces.
Cost Considerations: Medium vs. Large Green Egg
Price is one of the decisive factors when choosing between the two. The Large costs significantly more than the Medium.
As of the latest BGE pricing:
| Model | Approximate Base MSRP (Egg Only) | With Stand & Accessories |
|——-|——————————-|————————–|
| Medium | $800–$850 | Starts around $1,250 |
| Large | $1,000–$1,100 | Up to $1,600+ |
The accessories alone make the jump from Medium to Large a fairly substantial financial decision. You also should think ahead to which accessories suit your needs. For example, a convEGGtor upgrade for the Large is more expensive than for the Medium.
Investing in the Medium can be a wiser first step:
- Let you get accustomed to kamado cooking before upgrading.
- Provide a more affordable entrance point with impressive functionality.
However, if you already know you’ll need the greater capacity, investing in the Large from the outset may offer better long-term value.
Resale and Community Options
An additional pro: both the Medium and Large Eggs retain their value extremely well. Many owners upgrade or downgrade and easily resell their Egg used.
The market for used Big Green Eggs is robust—especially for the Large size. It’s an asset that can pay back a large portion of your original investment if well maintained.
Also, the BGE community is loyal and generous. Forums and Facebook groups often have tips, used equipment for sale, and insights from users of all experience levels.
Final Verdict: Which One Is Best for You?
Here’s a wrap-up of who should be opting for which model:
The Medium Big Green Egg Is Best For:
- Smaller space availability
- Singles and couples
- Budget-conscious buyers
- Beginners looking to try kamado cooking
- People prioritizing mobility or occasional use
The Large Big Green Egg Is Best For:
- Entertainers and large families
- Outdoor cooking enthusiasts and weekend chefs
- Grillers who smoke, bake, and roast frequently
- People looking to host without limitations
- Those who want to avoid “cooking in shifts”
Wrapping It All Up
Ultimately, both the Medium and Large Big Green Eggs can elevate your cooking game when used to their full potential. However, choosing the right size ensures that your investment meets your real-world needs, complements your lifestyle, and fits your available outdoor space.
Whether you’re dreaming about perfect sear marks on steaks, experimenting with smoked brisket, or baking a sourdough loaf outdoors, the Big Green Egg is a top-tier companion. Now that you’ve learned what makes each model unique and how they compare side-by-side, ask yourself a few questions:
– How much space do I have to work with?
– How frequently will I use the Egg?
– Will I cook for more than 5 people at a time?
– Do I want to explore more than just conventional grilling?
– What budget do I have in mind?
By answering these thoughtfully, you’ll be better positioned to answer the question, “Should I get a medium or large green egg?”
Whether you go medium or large, you’re investing in years of flavor-rich meals, cooking expertise, and backyard enjoyment. Choose confidently, and enjoy every flame-lit moment of your journey with the Big Green Egg.
Happy cooking!
What are the main differences between the Medium and Large Green Egg?
The Medium and Large Green Egg are both high-quality kamado-style ceramic grills, but they differ primarily in size and cooking capacity. The Medium Egg has a 187 square inch cooking surface and is well-suited for small families or individuals who enjoy grilling occasionally. Its smaller size allows for quicker heat-up times and more efficient fuel usage, making it ideal for weekday meals or limited outdoor spaces.
On the other hand, the Large Green Egg offers a spacious 213 square inch cooking area, making it better for larger families or those who frequently entertain guests. Its increased volume allows for more versatile cooking techniques, such as smoking large cuts of meat or baking multiple dishes at once. The larger size does mean longer preheating times and slightly higher fuel consumption, but for serious outdoor cooks, the added flexibility may be well worth it.
Which size is best for a small family or individual use?
For a small family of two to three people or an individual who enjoys grilling regularly, the Medium Green Egg is often the ideal choice. Its manageable dimensions allow for easy storage and efficient cooking without generating excessive heat. This size is especially attractive for those with limited outdoor space or for those who don’t want to commit to the higher fuel usage and cost of a larger model. It’s also perfect for preparing meals that don’t require multiple racks or large batch cooking.
In addition, the Medium Green Egg offers excellent versatility for searing steaks, smoking fish, or baking bread—making it a great all-around cooker for daily use. It heats up more quickly than the Large Egg, which is convenient when cooking for just a few people. If entertaining is limited and storage is a concern, the Medium Egg provides enough capacity for most grilling needs without unnecessary overhead.
How does the cooking capacity of the Large Green Egg compare to the Medium?
The Large Green Egg provides a significant increase in cooking capacity compared to the Medium model. With 213 square inches of cooking surface, it allows users to prepare multiple meals simultaneously and accommodate larger cuts of meat or batches of food. This makes it especially appealing to big families or frequent entertainers who enjoy hosting backyard cookouts, dinner parties, or BBQ events where a diverse menu is prepared outdoors.
In contrast, the Medium Egg’s 187 square inches are sufficient for everyday meals but can become limiting when preparing multi-course dishes or cooking for more than three or four people. The Large Egg also allows for better airflow and temperature control when cooking for extended periods, enhancing your ability to smoke, roast, or bake more consistently. If you frequently cook for groups, the added capacity of the Large Egg is likely worth considering.
What are the fuel consumption differences between the sizes?
Larger kamado grills like the Large Green Egg use more fuel than the Medium Egg because they have a larger chamber and require more charcoal to maintain consistent temperatures, especially during long cooks. While this difference may not be significant for occasional use, it can add up over time if you’re grilling or smoking daily. Those concerned with efficiency and cost management may find the Medium Egg more economical for regular meals.
However, the Large Egg’s superior insulation and heat retention capabilities help mitigate some of the added fuel costs, especially once it’s up to temperature. Its design allows for precise temperature control, which can help conserve fuel during long smoking sessions. If you’re comfortable with slightly higher fuel consumption for the sake of greater versatility and cooking volume, the Large Egg can be a worthwhile investment.
Which Egg is better for someone with limited outdoor space?
If your outdoor area is small, such as a balcony, compact patio, or narrow backyard, the Medium Green Egg’s smaller footprint and reduced height make it a more practical choice. It’s easier to fit within tight spaces and can be used safely in proximity to walls or fences without concern for excessive heat radiation. Additionally, the Medium Egg is often more portable, which is useful if you need to move or store it seasonally.
The Large Egg, while only slightly bigger, still requires a dedicated amount of space for both the grill itself and the recommended clearance for safety and ventilation. It’s ideal for spacious patios or backyard setups, but may overwhelm smaller outdoor environments. Its stand or table is also larger, which further affects where it can be placed. For those with restricted space, the Medium Egg strikes a better balance between performance and practicality.
Does the choice between Medium and Large affect versatility in cooking techniques?
The Large Green Egg offers greater versatility in cooking techniques due to its increased chamber size. It allows for advanced methods like smoking whole turkeys, roasting racks of ribs, or even baking several loaves of bread at the same time. The availability of accessories such as multi-level racks, convEGGtor inserts, and stone baking surfaces helps maximize its flexibility, making it a favorite among serious outdoor chefs.
In contrast, the Medium Green Egg is still impressively versatile but may require more strategic planning when multitasking with food. While it can smoke, bake, sear, and roast, the smaller internal volume can limit simultaneous cooking or the size of dishes that can be prepared. However, for those with simpler cooking needs and a desire for quick, flavorful meals, the Medium Egg remains a powerful and adaptable tool for mastering a wide variety of techniques.
What about price differences and value for money?
The Medium Green Egg typically comes at a lower price point than the Large Egg, which can be a decisive factor for those starting out with kamado cooking or working within a budget. Along with the lower initial cost, it requires less investment in accessories and fuel over time, making it a more economical option for everyday use. Additionally, its durability ensures long-term value, particularly for those who don’t need the added space or versatility of the larger model.
The Large Egg, while more expensive upfront, may provide better value for avid entertainers or serious cooks who regularly prepare large meals or experiment with different cooking styles. Its expanded capacity and performance can justify the higher cost if you frequently host gatherings or enjoy long, complex cooks. However, it’s essential to evaluate your typical usage before paying for features you may not fully utilize. Both models are durable investments, but choosing the right size ensures optimal returns on your purchase.